Best Zero Waste Toothpaste Brands For an Eco-Smile

Are there zero waste toothpaste brands you can buy? If you’re like me then you have probably gotten to the end of a tube of toothpaste and wondered if there are any plastic free toothpaste alternatives available?

You may have also wondered if eco friendly or natural toothpaste is as good as the traditional brands on the market. Well I’m here to tell you good news (and who doesn’t love a bit of good news right now!).

There are many zero waste toothpaste options on the market that are great for both adults and children. So you can brush your teeth, prevent tooth decay and help the planet!

Disclaimer: This article may have affiliate links to products mentioned throughout. If you were to purchase a product, I may make a small commission from the sale which supports this blog. Read my privacy, disclosure and cookie page for details.

My Zero Waste Toothpaste Journey

As an advocate for green living, my journey towards using eco friendly toothpaste or zero waste toothpaste began with a realisation: that traditional toothpaste tubes were harmful to the environment.

Coconut Oil

Initially, I experimented with coconut oil as a natural toothpaste substitute. While the idea seemed promising, the reality was somewhat unexpected. Although coconut oil left my mouth feeling clean, the absence of a familiar minty aftertaste took some getting used to. So despite its unconventional appeal, I appreciated its eco-friendly credentials but i wasn’t for me.

Baking Soda

Next, I turned to baking soda as another potential solution. it’s a common household staple and I had read that it can even remove tea and coffee stains! Whilst cleaning it offered a refreshing clean feeling after brushing (i.e. smooth teeth).

However, similar to my experience with coconut oil, the absence of a minty flavour left something to be desired. While effective, baking soda alone didn’t quite meet my expectations.

Toothpaste Tabs

Lastly, I decided to explore zero waste toothpaste tabs as a modern alternative. These compact, dissolvable tablets seemed like the perfect eco-friendly solution. They provided convenience and reduced plastic waste, ticking all the boxes for a sustainable oral care option.

However, as life often does, circumstances changed when I had my baby, things got on top of me and I ended up returning to traditional toothpaste for simplicity’s sake. Don’t judge me!

Lastly, I should mention that in order to have health teeth and gums you need to have toothpaste that contains the mineral fluoride to and prevent tooth decay.

A Fresh Start!

Now, I’m eager to resume my journey towards using zero waste toothpaste alternatives. This article serves as a reflection on the choices available I’ll pick what’s best for me, my husband and daughter.

In the coming weeks, I’ll be exploring a range of eco-friendly toothpaste and toothbrush options and sharing my thoughts and experiences with you. From vegan friendly and chemical based formulations to innovative packaging solutions.

I’m super excited to discover the best sustainable toothpaste brands and provide an honest review of my favourites.

Is Traditional Toothpaste Bad For The Environment?

In short yes, regular traditional toothpaste is harmful to the environment for a few reasons. According to Tooth Be Told since the 18950’s 8.3 billion metric tonnes of plastic. Much of that plastic has ended up in landfill waste or in the sea.

Here are a few other reasons why you should consider making the change to plastic free toothpaste:

1. Traditional toothpaste tubes are made of plastic which is created from fossil fuel and does not decompose. Tubes end up in landfill sites or our oceans.
2. Big traditional toothpaste brands engage in questionable labour and employment practices.
3. Toothpaste brands are not always toxin free toothpaste which are not good for animal and marine life after use.
4. Some traditional brands engage in greenwashing a tactic used to appear more sustainable than they actually are.

Why Natural Toothpaste is Better

Full disclosure I’m NOT a dentist but I’ve listed the environmental reasons why natural organic toothpaste is great for your teeth and better for the planet!

1. Eco toothpaste brands tend to avoid the use of animal products in toothpaste. Promising a cruelty free toothpaste for you and your family.
2. Zero waste toothpaste brands offer chemical free toothpaste.
3. People often ask the question ‘is toothpaste vegan or plant based toothpaste effective?’ and depending on the brand the answer is yes!
4. There are many options of zero waste toothpaste for sensitive teeth such as Georganics (see below)
5. There are many zero waste toothpaste with fluoride options available just like traditional toothpaste.

Toothpaste Vs Tooth Tablets

Below, I’ll compare both zero waste toothpaste and eco toothpaste tablets so you’re armed with the pros and cons or both options. I’ve highlighted both their pros and cons in terms of price, convenience, and environmental impact.

Toothpaste:

Pros:

1. Variety of Options: Traditional toothpaste comes in a wide range of formulations catering to various dental needs, such as sensitivity, whitening, and cavity prevention.
2. Familiarity and Convenience: Most people are used to using toothpaste, and it’s readily available in supermarkets and pharmacies. It’s also easy to dispense and use at home or if you go away.
3. Affordability: Eco and Traditional toothpaste is often more affordable than toothpaste tablets, particularly if bought in bulk or on sale.

Cons:

1. Packaging Waste: Most traditional toothpaste tubes are made of non-recyclable plastic, contributing to environmental pollution.
2. Ingredients: Some traditional toothpaste brands contain artificial ingredients, such as artificial sweeteners, palm oil and preservatives, which may be of concern to those seeking natural alternatives.
3. Limited Portability: Large toothpaste tubes may be inconvenient for travel or on-the-go use, requiring additional packaging or travel-sized containers.

Toothpaste Tablets:

Pros:

1. Reduced Packaging Waste: Zero waste toothpaste tablets typically come in minimalist packaging or recyclable containers, reducing plastic waste compared to traditional toothpaste tubes.
2. Portability: Zero waste toothpaste tablets are compact and lightweight, making them ideal for travel or camping. They eliminate the need for bulky toothpaste tubes.
3. Natural Ingredients: Many zero waste toothpaste tablet brands use natural ingredients, such as fluoride, xylitol, and essential oils, appealing to families seeking eco-friendly and natural oral care options.

Cons:

1. Higher Cost: Zero waste toothpaste tablets can be more expensive than traditional toothpaste on a per-use basis, especially premium or specialty formulations.
2. Limited Availability: While toothpaste tablets are gaining popularity, they may not be as readily available as traditional toothpaste in all stores, requiring families to purchase online or from specialty retailers.
3. Adaptation Period: Some people (cough cough me) may find it challenging to transition from traditional toothpaste to toothpaste tablets, particularly if they’re accustomed to the texture and taste of traditional toothpaste.

Analysis

So to sum up, while both toothpaste and toothpaste tablets offer effective oral hygiene, families must weigh the pros and cons of each option based on their priorities, including price, convenience, and environmental impact.

List of Top Zero Waste Toothpaste Brands

So now that we’ve covered the impact of traditional toothpaste vs zero waste toothpaste and we have looked at the pros and cons of toothpaste and toothpaste tablets. Let’s have a look at my fav zero waste toothpaste brands on the market at the moment.

I’ve tried to select brands that offer good oral care and dental care as well as fair price and can be purchased via their online shop.

The Dirt Coconut Oil Toothpaste

I have to admit, it’s an intriguing name. The Dirt Coconut Oil Toothpaste, has fun packaging! The colour of the paste is white and it’s made from clay, herbs and essential oils. A tube of toothpaste costs £8.00 which is a lot you can create a bundle and bulk buy to save ££s. Or it would make a unique zero waste gift set for a friend or loved one.

Nelson Naturals Toothpaste

What I like about Nelson’s Natural Toothpaste is that you can buy the brand via a number of online shops. Their packaging is in glass jars and metal lids so 100% recyclable and cruelty free ingredients. A jar of toothpaste costs £17 including shipping.

Scentcerae Tooth Nibs Solid Toothpaste

Scentcerae Tooth Nibs (£17 for a starter gift set) are like toothpaste tablets in that you pop them in your mouth to lather up and then brush with your toothbrush. Packaged in beautiful recycled cardboard boxes and made from coconut oil, matcha powder and dried fruits.

They also have fun flavours like pina colada. My only hesitation with this brand is the use of dried fruit which is sugary. I’m not sure how brushing on your teeth is a good idea. You’d need to check with your dentist first before using this as it’s not FDA approved.

Georganics Mineral Zero Waste Toothpaste Tablets

Georganics Mineral Toothpaste Tablets come in charcoal or regular tabs. They can be used by the WHOLE family meaning less waste and are priced at £9.95 per jar. You can buy once or create a subscription package whereby you review refills in cardboard bags! Georganics seem to have thought of everything here and are reasonably priced.

Tooth Be Told

Tooth Be Told offer vegan, plastic free and fluoride free toothpaste packaged in bamboo pots. They look beautiful and I love that they offer FREE shipping on all products. A pot of toothpaste costs £6.95.

Toothpaste Comparison Table

Let’s have a look at all the options now in a comparison table. In this comparison table, I’ve outlined the prices, weights, packaging types, shipping options, and ease of use for various eco-friendly toothpaste brands. The information provided should help you make the best decision based on price, packaging materials, shipping options, and ease of use.

Analysis

Based on the comparison table provided, let’s analyze the results:

1. Price: The Dirt Coconut Oil Toothpaste and Tooth Be Told offer the lowest prices, making them more budget-friendly options. Georganics Toothpaste Tablets also offer a competitive price, while Nelson Naturals Toothpaste and Scentcerae Tooth Nibs are relatively more expensive.
2. Weight: Nelson Naturals Toothpaste provides the largest quantity by weight, offering 93.6g in a glass jar. The Dirt Coconut Oil Toothpaste follows with 72g in a plastic tube, while Scentcerae Tooth Nibs come with 80 nibs in a bamboo container. Georganics Toothpaste Tablets provide 120 tablets in a glass jar, and Tooth Be Told offers a bamboo pot without specifying weight.
3. Packaging: Nelson Naturals Toothpaste stands out for its eco-friendly glass jar packaging, followed by Georganics Toothpaste Tablets. Scentcerae Tooth Nibs also use bamboo containers, while The Dirt Coconut Oil Toothpaste and Tooth Be Told utilize plastic and bamboo pots, respectively.
4. Shipping: Shipping options vary depending on the seller, with some brands offering free shipping, while others require additional fees. Tooth Be Told stands out for offering free shipping.
5. Ease of Use: The Dirt Coconut Oil Toothpaste and Tooth Be Told offer traditional toothpaste application methods, either squeezing from a tube or scooping from a pot. Nelson Naturals Toothpaste, Scentcerae Tooth Nibs, and Georganics Toothpaste Tablets require additional steps such as scooping, chewing, or dissolving before brushing.

For a family of four, the best option would depend on their specific priorities:

• Budget-Conscious Families: The Dirt Coconut Oil Toothpaste and Tooth Be Told are ideal choices due to their affordability.
• Eco-Conscious Families: Nelson Naturals Toothpaste and Georganics Toothpaste Tablets are recommended for their eco-friendly glass packaging, though Georganics Toothpaste Tablets also offer a competitive price.
• Convenience-Oriented Families: Families seeking convenience may prefer The Dirt Coconut Oil Toothpaste or Tooth Be Told for their familiar application methods.
• Minimalist Families: Scentcerae Tooth Nibs could be suitable for families looking to reduce packaging waste, as they come in a bamboo container and provide toothpaste nibs without additional packaging.

Ultimately, the best option for a family of four would depend on factors such as price, packaging materials, shipping options, and ease of use.

FAQ

Final Thoughts

Much like traditional shampoo and soap regular toothpaste is really bad for our planet. From the production of the single use plastic tubes to the harmful chemicals and additives added to the toothpaste it’s self. Zero waste toothpaste brands such as The Dirt, Nelsons Naturals, Scentcerae, Geoganics and Tooth Be Told offer a new alternative to dental care that is kind to your teeth and the planet! Georganics, The Dirt and Tooth Be Told offer the best value for money.

Subscribe and Go Green!

Want to level up your sustainability game? Then take our Sustainable Living Quiz to learn more about your sustainable living habits! I also have lots of other helpful green living blogs such as:

• Wild Deodorant Refill: A Greener Choice for A Sweat-Free Day

• Reusable Face Wipes: Greener Skin Care

• Eco-Friendly Toothbrush: Top 5